On almost every trek we describe in this magazine, someone else carries part of the load, cooks the evening meal or knows which of three faint paths leads to the pass. On Kilimanjaro it is a legal requirement to walk with a licensed guide; in the Simien Mountains a park scout with a rifle is mandatory; in the High Atlas a mule and muleteer are the normal way to move food between valleys; in Georgia, Armenia and Kyrgyzstan horses and their owners do the same work. Hiring people well is an expedition skill in its own right, and it is one that visitors get wrong more often than they get their gear wrong. This is what we have learned about paying, expecting and behaving fairly.
Understand who you are hiring
The roles differ, and confusing them causes friction. A guide is responsible for the route, decisions about weather and safety, and communication with authorities and villages. A cook feeds the group and manages food and fuel. Porters, muleteers and horsemen move loads, and are usually paid per animal or per fixed load rather than per person. On Kilimanjaro a group of two walkers commonly travels with a guide, an assistant guide, a cook and six to eight porters. In the Atlas or the Caucasus the same group might have one guide who also cooks and one muleteer with two animals.
Knowing the structure tells you where the money goes. In most of these regions the guide is paid a daily rate several times higher than a porter, and the guide often chooses and pays the crew. That is normal, but it means a fair price agreed with the guide does not guarantee fair pay lower down. Asking, politely and early, what porters and muleteers receive per day is not rude. It is the only way to know.
What fair pay looks like
Rates change with inflation and season, so we give orders of magnitude rather than figures. As a rule of thumb, a licensed mountain guide in these regions earns per day roughly what a skilled tradesperson earns, a cook somewhat less, and a porter or muleteer somewhat less again, plus food. On Kilimanjaro, the national park and porter welfare organisations publish minimum daily wages for porters, and reputable crews meet or exceed them. In Ethiopia, park scout fees are set by the park and paid at the office, while guides and cooks negotiate separately. In Morocco, mule hire is usually a daily rate that includes the muleteer.
The trap is bargaining a rate down to the point where the crew has to cut corners: fewer porters carrying heavier loads, a cook buying less food, a muleteer feeding the animal less. Twenty kilograms is the accepted maximum porter load on Kilimanjaro, and loads are weighed at the gates. We have seen loads well above that when a group insisted on a cheap price. A price that seems too good is usually being paid by someone else’s back.
What is expected of you
Local crews expect walkers to be clear about what they want, to keep to the agreed plan, and to treat the crew as colleagues on the same mountain rather than as staff in a hotel. Concretely, that means a few things we now do every time:
- Agree the price, the number of days, the number of crew and what is included, in writing if possible, before setting off
- Pay a deposit only for food and transport costs, and the balance at the end, as is customary
- Carry your own day pack with water, layers and first aid; porters carry camp, not you
- Eat what the cook makes and say so when it was good; food is a matter of pride everywhere we walk
- Keep the pace the guide sets on ascent days rather than racing ahead and waiting
There are also expectations about behaviour. In the Atlas villages and the Ethiopian highlands, walkers who sit and take tea with the crew, learn a dozen words of Tamazight or Amharic, and ask about families are treated very differently from those who retreat to a tent. In Kyrgyzstan, a shepherd family hosting a group in a yurt will expect guests to accept bread and tea, and refusing outright is a small insult.
Tipping: the part nobody explains
Tipping is where visitors feel most anxious, and it is where guidebook advice is often years out of date. On Kilimanjaro, tips are a large and expected part of crew income, and the convention is a group tip per crew member per day, with the guide receiving the most, then assistant guides and cook, then porters. A common structure is that the group’s tips for a week add up to roughly ten to fifteen percent of the trek cost, distributed by role. It is best given directly, person by person, at the final camp or gate, rather than handed to the guide to share.
In the Atlas and the Middle East, tipping is smaller and less formalised, but a day’s wage as a tip at the end of a week is welcome and expected. In the Caucasus and Central Asia, where the culture of tipping is weaker, a gift for the household that hosted you, or paying for the horse owner’s return journey, matters more than cash in an envelope. In Jordan, communities along the trail often host walkers in family homes and expect payment for the night and the meal, which is not a tip but the price of the hospitality, and should be paid without haggling.
When things go wrong
Most disputes come from three sources: the plan changed and nobody agreed who pays for extra days; the weather turned and the guide wanted to stop while the walkers wanted to go on; or a walker got sick and the crew had to abandon the itinerary. All three can be talked about on day one. We now agree in advance that the guide has the final word on safety, that extra days caused by weather are paid at the agreed daily rate, and that a group turning back because of illness still pays the crew for the days planned. That last point is the one most often argued over, and it is not really arguable. The crew turned down other work for those days.
If a guide behaves badly, or the crew is visibly mistreated, there are places to take it. Kilimanjaro’s park authority and the porter welfare organisations at the gates accept reports. National tourism offices in Georgia and Kyrgyzstan license guides and want to know. Raising concerns calmly is taken seriously far more often than visitors expect.
The relationship is the point
We have walked with muleteers who could read a coming storm from the smell of the air, cooks who baked bread in a hole in the sand, and scouts who knew every ibex on a cliff. None of that appears on an invoice. Hiring fairly is not charity; it is what makes the next group welcome in the next valley. Paying properly, expecting professionalism and being a decent guest are the same skill, worth practising as carefully as pitching a tent.
